Skip to main content

Fire: Igniting the sexual Taboos

Suggested Citation: Sinha, S. (2021, June 3). “Fire”: Igniting the sexual Taboos. Queer Academia. URL

“Fire”: Igniting the sexual Taboos | Stuti Sinha

 This essay explores the movie “Fire”, India’s first lesbian movie[1] released in November 1998, from a feminist perspective. It focuses on the overlap of Indian culture and sexuality.

Overview of the movie

Fire, a film by Deepa Mehta is about two sisters-in-law, Radha (Shabana Azmi) and Sita (Nandita Das), who are married to two brothers Ashok and Jatin. All of them live under the same roof. Both Radha and Sita were neglected emotionally and sexually by their husbands. Soon they discover that they love each other and establish a sexual relationship. What makes the movie more interesting is the fact that it is set within the boundaries of Indian culture within the late ‘90s.

Cultural Oppression and Sexuality

The movie depicts how women are not allowed to explore their own sexuality and if they do, are met with emotional and possibly physical violence because they are blamed for destroying the sanctity of marriage. “A woman without a husband is like plain rice: bland and unappetizing,”  says Sita further she adds “it must be an Indian saying”, which outlines the condition of women in Indian society during that period of the ‘90s. So much so that a character Ashok says, “It is sin in the eyes of God and man”.  In Indian cinema, homosexuals are always depicted as a comic character and always are the victim of taunting and objectification[2]. Films like “Kya kool Hain Hum”, “Masti” and many more feature the Queer community in a horrific stereotypical manner. In most of the films, they are portrayed as beggars, prostitutes, or molesters who seem to be preying on the hero sexually without their consent[3].

Even though the movie “Fire” received mixed reviews from critics and the Indian press after its release across the country, the movie faced many hurdles and sparked protest in many cities because of its theme of “lesbianism” and because the names of the main protagonists “Sita” and “Radha” derived from Hindu epics and thus allegedly “hurt” Hindu sentiments as well.[4]  Just a few weeks after its release, the film made the news with accounts of attacks by Shiv Saniks who targeted the cinema halls in Mumbai and Delhi where “Fire” was being screened. By the news of a Special screening which was held for women only in Mumbai fueled the actions of Shiv Sena. The reasons cited by the members of Shiv Sena for the film's offensiveness ranged from its themes of “lesbianism”. As a result “Fire” was withdrawn from the movie theatres in these cities. However, the “Fire” controversy can claim the credit for making the plight of lesbians in India publicly visible. [5]

Intersectional Feminism in Indian Context

In Indian culture, women are not only denied to exercise their sexuality by their family but also by religion, caste, nationality, status, culture, gender in society. Here the third wave of feminism in the Indian context comes into the picture.[6] Each person has their struggle against oppression and unique experience of discrimination at different intensities. For example, discrimination faced by a North-Indian infertile lesbian middle-class woman might be different from a South-Indian lesbian high-class woman. This is because of the class boundaries they belong to and also regional differences. To address the issue of all women belonging to any marginalized community, a proper framework is required which recognizes the “difference” of oppression[7]. As shown in the movie, because of Radha’s infertility, her husband Ashok pursued celibacy which he often tests in bed with Radha. He defines Radha’s participation in the test as her “duty” towards him and she being an obedient wife is obliged to do the test to help Ashok maintain celibacy. In a patriarchal society, women are presented as objects who are no different from “baby-making machines” for the patriarchal family. Here the oppression and dominance faced by Radha are different from other women belonging to different social boundaries.[8]

Symbolic end of the Movie

At the very end of the movie occurs when Radha is caught in fire, after her husband Ashok finds out about her lesbian relationship with Sita, and doesn’t try to save her. However, she survives and joins Sita at the Nizamuddin Dargah. This episode is a clear reference to Ramayana, where Goddess Sita, walks through fire to prove her purity and devotion towards her husband Ram. Similarly, in the movie, Radha proves that her innocence, her love for Sita is pure and beyond the norms of society. This love is vindicated by her safe passage through fire.[9] The patriarchal ideology which controls the sexual choice of the woman in Indian culture is challenged at the end of the movie because both Radha and Sita end all cultural bonds with their society and family and seek the end of their heterosexual marriages in order to be together with each other. “See what you can’t see, see without looking”, a dialogue of one of the characters. If one tries to analyze this line in reference to Radha’s life then it can be concluded that even though she could not lead a happy life with Ashok, she was able to lead one with Sita.

Conclusion

In conclusion, I would like to say that a woman's sexuality should not be used to distinguish between the so-called “ideal” woman and a “substandard” woman. As said by Sita in the movie “There is no word in our language that can describe what we are, how we feel for each other”. Homosexuality is widely considered a western concept but in reality, it is not.[10] Many similar Radhas and Sitas are demanding their recognition and claiming their space in Indian society even today. And movies like “Fire” might bring an effective change in contemporary Indian society.

Written by: Stuti Sinha

Edited by: Sanket Sharma

About the Author: Stuti is a first year student at Lloyd Law College, Greater Noida

 

[1] Ghosh, S. G. (2019, Feb 04). Film flashback: ‘Fire’ was the first Indian film to bring women in love out of the shadows. https://scroll.in/reel/911448/film-flashback-fire-was-the-first-indian-film-to-bring-women-in-love-out-of-the-shadows 

[2] Pooja, J., & Rekha, K. P. (2018). Indian Cinema and Its Portrayal of Emotional Complexities of LGBT Community. International Journal of Pure and Applied Mathematics, Vol 119 No. 12, 2853-2870.

https://acadpubl.eu/hub/2018-119-12/articles/7/1818.pdf 

[3] Kaur, P. (2017). Gender, Sexuality and (Be) longing: The Representation of Queer (LGBT) in Hindi Cinema. Amity Journal of Media & Communication Studies (ISSN 2231 – 1033), Vol. 7, No. 1, 22-30.

https://amity.edu/UserFiles/asco/journal/ISSUE50_3.%20Pushpinder.pdf

[4] Kapur, R. (2000,, Spring). Too Hot to Handle: The Cultural Politics of "Fire". Feminist Review, (64),, 53-64.

http://www.jstor.org/stable/1395702

[5] John, M., & Niranjana, T. (1999). Mirror Politics: 'Fire', Hindutva and Indian Culture. Economic and Political Weekly, 34(10/11), 581-584. Retrieved May 12, 2021, from http://www.jstor.org/stable/4407727

[6] P., A. N. (2017, Feb 13). Intersectional Feminism 101: Why It’s Important And What We Must Remember. https://feminisminindia.com/2017/02/13/indian-intersectional-feminism-101/ 

[7] P., A. N. (2017, Feb 13). Intersectional Feminism 101: Why It’s Important And What We Must Remember.

https://feminisminindia.com/2017/02/13/indian-intersectional-feminism-101/ 

[8] D., F.,. B. (2013). Fire, Water and The Goddess: The Films of Deepa Mehta and Satyajit Ray as Critiques of Hindu Patriarchy. Journal of Religion & Film, Vol 17: Iss. 2, Article 3.

https://digitalcommons.unomaha.edu/jrf/vol17/iss2/3 

[9] R., P. (2018). Suffocating Shell of Sexuality: Politics of Lesbian Identity in Fire. IJRAR- International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews,, Vol 5(Issue 3), 1774-1777. http://ijrar.com/upload_issue/ijrar_issue_1539.pdf 

[10] Vanita, Ruth, "Homosexuality in India: Past and Present" (2002). Global Humanities and Religions Faculty Publications. 5.

https://scholarworks.umt.edu/libstudies_pubs/5

 

Comments

  1. Utpal ladlaJune 4, 2021 at 5:54 AM

    I must say, better observed , having a powerful message and you have done it very well .
    Keep it up stuti👍✌

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why do we need an LGBT inclusive curriculum in Schools | Aashi Singh

  Suggested Citation: Singh, A. (2021, May 31). Why do we need an LGBT+ inclusive curriculum in schools. Queer Academia. URL On 6 th September 2018, Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code was decriminalized by the Supreme Court of India. This historic ruling was a ray of hope for the LGBTQ+ community of India. But despite this positive step by the Court, LGBTQ youth continue to face bullying, harassment, and discrimination. In May 2020, a 21-year-old queer woman committed suicide after being forced to undergo conversion therapy by her family (Deol, 2020). In July 2020, Mumbai Mirror reported an incident wherein an LGBTQ youth from Kolkata was beaten up at night by a group of policemen and arrested without any charges. The individual’s phone was taken away by the policemen and several homophobic insults were hurled at him. He was detained by the police for twelve hours and was released on bail the following morning (Nag, 2020). These are only some of the several incidents of abuse fa
Post a Comment
Read more

Queer Affirmative Curriculum and Teaching Pedagogies for Indian Schools

  Suggested Citation: Verma, T. (2021, May 31). Queer Affirmative Curriculum and Teaching Pedagogies for Indian Schools. Queer Academia. URL Queer Affirmative Curriculum and Teaching Pedagogies for Indian Schools | Teena Verma Paradoxes are inevitable. In a land where ancient texts like Arthashastra, Manusmriti, and Kamasutra traverse themes of same-sex attraction and behavior, and Hindu scriptures include stories of dieties being born from the union of same-sex gods, for example- “Bhagiratha'' was born from the coupling of two women, and God Ayyappa from the sexual intercourse between the Gods Vishnu and Shiva, it is bewildering to observe atrocities against homosexuals (Conner, Sparks, & Sparks, 1998).  In the domain of queer acceptance, it needs to be acknowledged that some significant feats have indeed been made like the decriminalization of Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code in 2018 but the fight for equality is still not over as even after three years, the law doe
Post a Comment
Read more

What's a boy?Addressing issues of masculinity | Aashi Singh

 Suggested Citation: Singh, A. (2021, July 9). What's a boy? Addressing issues of masculinity. Queer Academia. URL. Gender rules every aspect of an individual’s life. From clothing to career, it defines what is accepted and what isn’t. Gender roles and norms are taught to children at a very young age. Girls are taught to play with dolls and are expected to like pink, whereas boys are taught to play with trucks and are supposed to like blue. Women are deemed as ‘weak’, ‘emotional’ and ‘submissive’ whereas men are labelled as ‘strong’, ‘aggressive’ and ‘dominant’ (Gupta, 2017). Men are constantly told to live up to certain standards to be respected. If they don’t fit into the specified gender norms then they are shamed and bullied both by family members as well as their peers. This has a severe psychological impact that is often ignored. According to a report by the National Crime Records Bureau titled “Accidental Deaths and Suicides in India 2019”, out of every 100 suicides, 70%
Post a Comment
Read more

The Taboo of Female Masturbation and its Relation to the Orgasm Gap

  Suggested Citation: Papadakou, C. (2021, May 31). The Taboo of Masturbation and its Relation to the Orgasm Gap. Queer Academia. URL The Taboo of Masturbation and its Relation to the Orgasm Gap | Christiana Papadakou In heterosexual relationships, one cannot help but notice that at times gender inequality exists. More specifically, there is a prevalent phenomenon called the orgasm gap – by definition, the orgasm gap is the large inconsistency in the frequency between males orgasming when engaging in heterosexual intercourse, in comparison to women (Jordan, 2019). In a survey conducted by Wade and colleagues, out of a sample of 985 undergraduates at the University of Wisconsin-Madison it was reported that 91% of men experienced an orgasm in their sexual engagements when only 39% of women said the same (Akers et al., 2020). In a similar study conducted with a sample of Canadian people above the age of 18, more than 87% of men reported having an orgasm in their sexual relations, but less
Post a Comment
Read more

Gender Equality in Teacher Training

  Suggested Citation: Sunil, A. (2021, May 31). Gender Equality in Teacher Training. Queer Academia. URL Gender Equality in Teacher Training | Aishwarya Sunil UNICEF defines gender equality as “equal rights and opportunities for girls and boys to help all children fulfill their potential.” This definition concerns itself with bridging the gap between only two genders. It fails to include individuals whose identity lies outside of the gender dichotomy. Such exclusionary mode of thinking is also reflected in policies formulated by the government such as the National Education Policy released in 2020. The NEP mentioned that it will consider "full equity and inclusion" as the bedrock of education-related decisions but it aims to do so by providing "equitable quality education for girls as well as transgender students”. The document makes no mention of lesbian, gay, bisexual, or any of the other members of the queer community. It continues to look at gender in terms of binari
1 comment
Read more

FAMILY AND IDENTITY IN INDIA | Tanisha Singh

Context: The following paper is an essay on my views about the Family, its constituents, the inter and intra dynamics of it within the society and gender and its conception, in the Indian context in particular, based on the text given as well as what emerged for me during the class discourse. The essay sort of ties together all the three questions posed in this paper, without necessarily having a demarcation for each answer separately. I have tried to make points that each add to and apply to all three questions of this paper, which all add up to make one big point in the essay. Since our experience of concepts of the Family, Gender, and the Couple all coexist together and parallelly forming a holistic experience, I felt it most natural to write in a way that one idea flows and feeds into the other as a holistic thought, without necessarily or entirely separating the different questions posed in this paper. Any couple or any sub-unit of relationship exists within a larger social group
Post a Comment
Read more

Is Gay Rights All About Gay Sex?

Suggested Citation: Hammish, R. S. (2021, September 6). IS GAY RIGHTS ALL ABOUT GAY SEX?. Queer Academia. URL. “Are we, cis-hetero (they used the S-word that are used for heteros, and I deliberately am abstaining from using it) people, having a pride month for being heteros? Are we announcing to everyone around us that we are cis-heteros?” asked Mugil, a close friend of mine, and they further added, “Nowadays, there are a lot of series that are trying to overly normalise homosexuality.” Mugil definitely was a guy who laughed for those silly stereotypical gay jokes in movies, and at present, Mugil seems to miss all those idiotic jokes when homosexuals are shown in a positive light.    Mugil’s homophobia seems to be different from the usual cat-calling and slur-using hatred that most of the gays (yes, I am using it as a noun) are used to hearing. There is an element of unwilling acceptance and fear in this hatred. Acceptance, because this person understands that being gay is normal. Thou
1 comment
Read more

Need for Feminism in Indian Education System

  Suggested Citation: Sinha, S. (2021, June 3). Need for Feminism in Indian Education System. Queer Academia. URL   Need for Feminism in Indian Education System | Satyawati Sinha It has been seventy-four years since India gained independence and yet Indian women do not have the freedom to walk the streets freely. They continue to be harassed, raped and murdered in broad daylight. In April 2021, The Hindu reported that a man stabbed his wife to death in the crowded area of Rohini in Delhi while people watched. The video of the gruesome incident even went viral on social media platforms. The accused said that the reason he stabbed his wife was that he didn’t want her to work and suspected her of having an extra-marital affair. The ‘Crime in India’ 2019 report by the National Crime Records Bureau’s (NCRB) revealed that there has been a 7.3% increase from 2018 in the number of crimes against women. 30.9% of the crimes were registered under ‘Cruelty by Husband or his Relatives', 21.
10 comments
Read more